News

Westpac CEO explains commission cut decision

Westpac chief executive Catherine McGrath explains why the bank is ending trail commissions on home loans and says the move isn't impacting applications.

Tuesday, November 04th 2025

McGrath told TMMOnline a key driver of its move to end trail commission came about after the Commerce Commission’s investigation into retail banking and making sure “that we lined up consumer interests with our own."

"There was a bit of a discussion happening at the time about whether trail commission was fully aligned in terms of making sure that everybody was incentivised to make sure that individuals got the best deal for themselves.”

She says there were other factors behind the decision too, but would not elaborate. When asked what these were she says: “(I) haven't got the full list of other considerations that we took into account at the time.”

“A primary driver was about making sure that incentives were all lined up for freedom, freedom of movement. And haven't got the full list of other considerations that we took into account at the time.”

She acknowledges that “it's been tricky in terms of the conversation with advisers, but they were really clear with us on their feedback, and we amended our approach based on that feedback.”

”I think we did do a good job at listening to the feedback that we were given, and we did change our approach as a consequence of that. And what I see now, and we've been pretty thoughtful about making sure that it's highly competitive moving forward, and aligning with industry standards.”

She does not think it will impact the amount of business mortgage advisers send to Westpac.

At September 30, 56.7% of the bank's overall book had been orginated by advisers, and in the six-month reporting period advisers accounted for 66% of flows.

She says; “What I'm seeing now is good flow coming through from the brokers.”

“My reflection on that is that the listening that we did, and the change of approach was really important in terms of our relationship with the brokers moving forward.”

“I know that brokers have their customers best interests at heart, and so if we're offering great price and a good service turnaround, then I expect that we will continue to be at that will continue to be reflected in our relationships with brokers.”

"What we've done is we've aligned broadly the way that we remunerate brokers in the same way that two other providers have done in the market. And I think that the pricing that we've put in place is very competitive and reinforces the importance that we see in the broker channel."

She denies it is a move by the bank to try and increase flows through its proprietary channels (branches) as many have suggested.

“No, it was about making sure that we had a pricing structure that we think is resilient for the longer term and completely aligns brokers interests with those of their customers,” she says.

McGrath says the bank has done well in the home loan space as it’s “doing some really smart things on pricing.”

“We were the first bank to drop rates below 5% ,” she says. “We're the first bank to put a total spread across the terms below 5% as well.”

“The other thing that we've been working quite hard on is our service levels, so the speed at which people can get Yes. And so I think service has been good and pricing has been good in market.”

“We certainly looked at key terms where we thought we could price quite assertively in the market, and chose to do that, which is why you'll have seen us pricing differently to some of the other banks, and leading some of that pricing at times as well.”

Despite that Westpac has been slightly under in terms of market share.

Comments

On Tuesday, November 04th 2025 10:53 am Amused said:

McGrath told TMMOnline a key driver of its move to end trail commission came about after the Commerce Commission’s investigation into retail banking and making sure “that we lined up consumer interests with our own." Consumer interests? Sorry but Westpac are essentially thumbing their nose at the Commerce Commission by not having changed to a 24-month clawback model on the 15th of October when they elected to axe trail commission and increase upfront commissions to 90 basis points. Westpac have so far only said to advisers that they will be changing to a 24-month claw back model early next year, but no definite date has been provided. Current Westpac clawback policy remains 100% at 0-15 months and 50% at 16-26 months following settlement. The Commerce Commission has stated the existing lengthy clawback periods are an anti-competitive practice that deters borrowers from refinancing, so it's a terrible look for both Westpac (and BNZ) that these main banks still haven’t followed ANZ’s decision over 248 days ago to move to 24 months with clawbacks now diminishing on a pro-rata basis every 30 days. It took ASB an agonising 213 days to bring their own clawback policy in-line with ANZ’s but Westpac and BNZ are now setting a new low standard for the banking industry in terms of acting in the best interests of consumers whilst also demonstrating with their delay that they do not value the business they receive from mortgage advisers. As for Westpac chief executive’s denial that the bank is trying to increase flows through its proprietary channels why is Westpac cancelling trail to mortgage advisers but still continuing to pay trail to customers who source a home loan directly from Westpac via Dosh?

On Tuesday, November 04th 2025 10:53 am Dcwhyte said:

If the CEO does not believe that the change in the commssion structure will affect the inflow of business, it must mean that something other than commission motivates Advsers to recommend a lender like Westpac. Acknowledging that Advisers have their clients' interests at heart seems to contradict the CommComm's view that lender commissions distort Adviser conduct. Shout out to Nick Hakes at FANZ and the CEO Forum for helping Westpac to adopt a less unacceptable stance. So now NZ has three major banks flying in the face of the global regulatory trend to encourage ongoing client service, care, and support. Is this the kind of conduct CoFI is meant to consider?

On Tuesday, November 04th 2025 11:08 am Valkyrie6 said:

BNZ need to come out now and let the industry know what their own stance is on trial commission. Of course, this conversation is likely already being had with the head groups/aggregators not that advisers will get to have any input! Advisers should stop putting any business to BNZ until they confirm what changes they are potentially going to make to trail and the commission model and when.

On Tuesday, November 04th 2025 12:53 pm Dcwhyte said:

If the CEO does not believe that the change in the commssion structure will affect the inflow of business, it must mean that something other than commission motivates advisers to recommend a lender like Westpac. Acknowledging that Advisers have their clients' interests at heart seems to contradict the CommComm's view that lender commissions distort Adviser conduct. Shout out to Nick Hakes at FANZ and the CEO Forum for helping Westpac to adopt a less unacceptable stance. So now NZ has three major banks flying in the face of the global regulatory trend to encourage ongoing client service, care, and support. Is this the kind of conduct CoFI is meant to consider?

On Tuesday, November 04th 2025 1:14 pm Amused said:

@ dcwhyte – do you happen to know what Westpac’s original stance to the industry was around its removal of trail commission? I ask this for the simple reason that mortgage advisers were completely shut out of any of the negotiations that aggregators (head groups) or associations had with Westpac. We even had one head group trying to tell its members that it was the only group to get to speak to Westpac. Advisers I think would like to know what actually changed between the time that Westpac first announced (to advisers) their intention to cease paying trail on the 2nd of October to when they officially communicated their final plans on the 15th of October.

On Wednesday, November 05th 2025 9:59 am Dcwhyte said:

@Amused - good question - can I please refer you to Nick at FANZ to respond? Discussions within the CEO Forum are within Nick's remit.

On Wednesday, November 05th 2025 11:43 am Amused said:

@ dcwhyte - Respectfully why have FANZ and the various aggregators (head groups) not already told advisers what changes they managed to secure from Westpac? You'd think that they would be telling their members loudly "hey guys, good news! We went into bat for you as your advocate and got Westpac to soften their original stance" To date mortgage advisers have heard nothing on this subject. Why is that? It's a simple question that mortgage advisers around the country would appreciate been answered truthfully now please. What actually changed between the time that Westpac first announced (to advisers) their intention to cease paying trail on the 2nd of October to when they officially communicated their final plans on the 15th of October?

On Wednesday, November 05th 2025 2:02 pm Valkyrie6 said:

FANZ ? aren't they the old PAA and NZMBA merged, banks do not even acknowledge these associations even exist now and back in the past, FANZ has no teeth and are complete waste of membership money.

Unity First Home Buyer special 3.99
ICBC 4.25
SBS FirstHome Combo 4.29
Co-operative Bank - First Home Special 4.35
TSB Special 4.39
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.45
ANZ Special 4.49
ASB Bank 4.49
SBS Bank Special 4.49
Unity Special 4.49
Westpac Special 4.49
Westpac Special 4.45
SBS Bank Special 4.49
BNZ - Std 4.49
Kiwibank Special 4.49
TSB Special 4.49
AIA - Go Home Loans 4.49
ANZ Special 4.49
ASB Bank 4.49
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.49
ICBC 4.59
Wairarapa Building Society 4.59
SBS Bank Special 4.99
Westpac Special 4.99
ICBC 4.99
BNZ - Std 4.99
AIA - Go Home Loans 5.15
ASB Bank 5.15
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 5.19
ANZ 5.39
TSB Special 5.39
Kiwibank Special 5.39
Kainga Ora 5.49
SBS FirstHome Combo 3.44
AIA - Back My Build 3.54
SBS Construction lending for FHB 3.74
CFML 321 Loans 4.25
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 5.30
Co-operative Bank - Standard 5.30
ICBC 5.39
Heartland Bank - Online 5.45
Kiwibank - Offset 5.80
Kiwibank 5.80
ANZ 5.89

More Stories

Market recovery signals consistent with interest rate falls

Monday, November 03rd 2025

Market recovery signals consistent with interest rate falls

The early stages of a property recovery could have appeared in the past two months, Kelvin Davidson, Cotality chief property economist says.

Another swipe at property investors

Thursday, October 30th 2025

Another swipe at property investors

Labour’s capital gains tax of 28% on residential and commercial property won’t deter investors who invest for cashflow, Nick Gentle, iFind Property founder and buyer’s agent says.

Capital gains tax almost irrelevant – English

Monday, October 20th 2025

Capital gains tax almost irrelevant – English

Former Finance Minster Bill English says the days of guaranteed capital gains in the housing market are over,

Thursday, October 09th 2025

New rules for meth contaminated houses

REINZ welcomes regulation of methamphetamine contamination in rental housing.