RBNZ adds new option to DTI consultation

The Reserve Bank (RBNZ) has started consultation on debt-to-income ratios, but added a new, and more sensible option.

Wednesday, November 24th 2021

This could involve making banks impose tougher risk-assessment measures on would-be borrowers.

The RBNZ wants comment from the finance industry on so-called debt serviceability restrictions (DSRs).

It is the latest in a series of measures to reduce banking sector vulnerability to an over heated property market.

The RBNZ says even though banks in this country are well-capitalised, the combination of very high debt levels and unsustainable house prices poses financial stability risks.

Its main method of dealing with this is the well-publicised Loan-to-Value-Ratio (LVR). This limits banks to no more than 10% of first home sales going to people with a deposit of less than 20%.

But it is now going further and consulting with the public and the industry over the viability of DSRs.

Of these, the best known is the Debt to Income Ratio (DTI). The RBNZ has already signaled its intention to consult on this and is now formally inviting comment.

Some banks have already anticipated a move with the BNZ saying a multiple of six is the level it will use in its own DTI.

The Reserve Bank is also looking at another sort of DSR: a floor on the test interest rates used by banks in their loan serviceability assessments.

These test the ability of borrowers to continue repaying their loans if interest rates rise above the level they were at when the loan was first taken out.

If approved, this would standardise the way banks assess the dependability of a loan, which they currently can vary depending on the wealth of a loan applicant.

It could also mean borrowers would have to be prepared to demonstrate they could face a higher potential interest rate than they are assessed on at present.

At this stage the RBNZ is not planning to implement either method, but it wants to have them ready in case of trouble.

A former Reserve Bank official, now an independent economist, thinks of the two methods under consideration, a floor on serviceability assessments is by far the better of the two options.

Ian Harrison, of Tailrisk Economics (pictured), says DTI is far too simplistic, since interest rates that go up and down can complicate a simple comparison between income and debt. A floor would work far better.

“Banks have a test rate, they don't just look at your current interest rate but they look at a higher interest rate, that is your test rate, and often that is about 6%.

Harrison says banks need to know that borrowers could service a loan at a higher rate in future than is being offered at present, to ensure their money is safe.

Amending the way banks make that judgment would be far more reliable in the fight to safeguard monetary system from risky debt than a simple DTI.

This view however contrasts with the RBNZ's belief that DTI restrictions would work better.


On Wednesday, November 24th 2021 10:57 am Andy the adviser said:

The Reserve Bank has created this problem. It should be up to the Reserve Bank to fix it. Making it harder to purchase a home by threatening to increase interest rates well above inflation rates, instigating theoretical debt servicing calculations instead of using ACTUAL verified borrower budgets is just going to lead to trouble. The only reason that homeowners are going to lose is if they HAVE to sell their house for less than they borrowed. With banks already ensuring a 20% equity gap, the banks are unlikely to lose. The only reasons that homeowners would need to sell at a loss would be loss of income, usually brought on by poor economic decisions made by the Reserve Bank. This includes over-stimulation, and unnecessary fiddling with the OCR. Let's not forget that the only reason house prices are so high is all the extra money being printed and being brought back in to the country by returnees chasing short supply. Reducing the money supply is the only option here - a road leading to disaster for sure. Oh, and throw in the inaccurate way in which inflation is calculated. How can inflation be less than 5%, when house prices are rising at 30%? The answer is simple. Forget about crystal gazing, theories and economic modelling. Look at reality. As has been said - the only way to accurately predict the future is to create it yourself.

On Wednesday, November 24th 2021 11:13 am Jonny Good Guy said:

If they did any of this why would we need 5 banks? This is anti-competitive behavior from the RB. Then close them all down and have one. There would be no difference between them.

On Thursday, November 25th 2021 8:43 am Missy said:

Rb is creating a huge disaster, the banks are making huge margins over the ocr it is so criminal. Jist making nz more a rich country and more people homeless and starving

Heartland Bank - Online 1.85
HSBC Premier 2.19
HSBC Special 2.25
Kainga Ora - First Home Buyer Special 2.25
China Construction Bank Special 2.65
TSB Special 3.29
SBS Bank Special 3.45
The Co-operative Bank - First Home Special 3.45
ICBC 3.49
Resimac 3.54
First Credit Union Special 3.59
Heartland Bank - Online 2.35
HSBC Premier 2.45
China Construction Bank Special 2.65
Resimac 3.89
TSB Special 3.94
SBS Bank Special 3.99
ICBC 4.05
First Credit Union Special 4.09
ASB Bank 4.15
AIA 4.15
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.35
China Construction Bank Special 2.99
HSBC Premier 3.19
Resimac 4.29
SBS Bank Special 4.69
TSB Special 4.70
Westpac Special 4.95
China Construction Bank 4.95
ICBC 4.95
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.99
BNZ - Classic 4.99
Kiwibank Special 5.15
ANZ Blueprint to Build 2.03
Heartland Bank - Online 2.25
ASB Back My Build 2.29
Resimac 3.39
Select Home Loans 4.09
Bluestone 4.09
Kiwibank 4.25
Kiwibank Special 4.25
Kiwibank - Offset 4.25
ICBC 4.25
China Construction Bank 4.49

More Stories

Auckland market turning for investors

Thursday, January 20th 2022

Auckland market turning for investors

Weaker prices for houses, particularly in Auckland, could mean the start of the long-anticipated downturn in the market.

Cracks appearing in housing market

Tuesday, January 18th 2022

Cracks appearing in housing market

A mortgage is not just getting more expensive as interest rates rise. A mortgage is now hard to get full stop, says Jarrod Kerr, Kiwibank chief economist.

Minister orders enquiry into CCCFA

Friday, January 14th 2022

Minister orders enquiry into CCCFA

Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs David Clark has acknowledged concerns with the CCCFA and ordered an enquiry.

CCCFA “not understood” by politicians

Monday, January 10th 2022

CCCFA “not understood” by politicians

The ACT Party believes the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act (CCCFA) was not properly understood when it went through parliament and is now asking for a review.