Auckland housing crisis nearly over

ASB economists reckon Auckland's housing crisis is coming to an end, but it is not the same story for the rest of the country.

Tuesday, November 16th 2021

Auckland’s housing shortfall crisis will be over in about a year’s time, ASB economists say.

At June this year Auckland has an undersupply of 20,000 houses, but this shortage will likely drop to under 10,000 by June next year and to zero at some point late next year and potentially shifting to surplus over 2023, according to the economists.

This suggests the booming construction sector cannot be sustained beyond 2022 without a strong recovery in net migration and population growth.

Statistics New Zealand’s recently updated regional population estimates reveal large shifts in internal migration with strong population growth in the regions over the past year, while Auckland had a drop in its population.

The country’s closed international border has choked off population growth into Auckland and, coupled with high rates of housing construction, has meant the housing shortage in the country’s biggest city has dropped at a faster pace than expected.

However, ASB’s economists believe housing consent figures alone likely overstate the growth in Auckland’s housing supply as there has been increased brown-field development where a number of townhouses or apartments are replacing existing dwellings that have been demolished or removed. Construction delays due to shortages of materials and labour might also lead to lower completion rates over the coming year.

“Nonetheless, Auckland is likely close to having its shortage met – this could happen in 2022 depending on the region’s population growth and the completion rate of new building consents.” says chief economist Nick Tuffley.

This presents the growing risk that Auckland could become over supplied with housing in 2023. “Whether this happens, or not, largely depends on how quickly New Zealand’s international border opens up over 2022 to permanent and long-term arrivals and how strong the recovery in net migration is over 2022.

“We are assuming a fairly conservative and gradual pick-up in net migration, so there is scope for population growth to exceed our forecasts – in which case the construction cycle would cool down at a more gradual pace than we currently anticipate,” says Tuffley.

For the rest of the country it is a different story. While Auckland has made great progress in closing the gap, the decline in the shortage throughout the rest of the country was modest over the past year given the strong shift in internal migration from Auckland to the regions.

Meanwhile, the proposed Resource Management Amendment Bill, which will enable more higher density developments to take place, will help land-locked cities such as Wellington reduce its own housing crisis which has become acute in recent years, says Tuffley.

The Bill allows for a more rapid supply response and for dense housing construction in areas that are closer to CBD and transport networks and that have been previously blocked by powerful/active NIMBY’s. It should, says Tuffley, prevent housing shortages developing to the same extent again.

While the new rules, allowing three houses of three stories to be developed on most sites without resource consent, do not kick-in until August next year - and some elements in 2023 - there is some risk it could see housing construction held up for longer than needed to close the supply gap, he says.

“But we believe that if developers see housing demand soften and house price growth slow over the first half of next year, then construction demand will likely follow suit. “

Next Article

Hot in Hawke's Bay


On Tuesday, November 16th 2021 12:55 am Dougal MacGibbon said:

The last thing this country needs is rampant population growth again. The immigration policies of the Key Govt did more to damage the many advantages that living in NZ has, than any other Govt in the last 50 years. The freedoms and enjoyment of our country has diminished hugely with the push to overpopulate this with immigrants and $2 tourists bringing nothing, but taking plenty. Covid restrictions has meant the citizens could actually enjoy their own country again. The idiocy of using immigration to produce a positive economy is a flawed theory and has massive negative impacts on the current citizens. If the building industry needs to wind down, then the foreign labour imported by industry to profit from the boom can simply return to their homes again.

On Tuesday, November 16th 2021 10:35 pm Janice Powell said:

I totally agree with the above letter. Other countries in the world have done the same and they have spoilt their natural wonders, habitat and as a result have ended up with an ecological nightmare. NZer's choose to live here for the slower pace of life, simplicity, clean air, natural beauty and low population base. If you want a high-flying career and rat race go to New York, Los Angeles or London, etc.

On Wednesday, November 17th 2021 6:49 pm Glenn Morris said:

I love the diversity and energy new migrants bring. When I grew up in the 1950's / 60's the bulk of the immigrants were 10 pound poms. They were focused on fish and chips, foot ball with a strange round ball, and trade unionists. New people from all over the world bring and share. They arrive not demanding things stay the same as their own country. A generous people giving each other a helping hand up is the sort of country I want. You are welcome in my country even if you do not look and sound like me.

On Thursday, November 18th 2021 8:42 am Helen Mountfort said:

Well, hooray, the property crisis is nearly over, but how about try telling that to the thousands if not millions of young people who are priced out of the property market?

Heartland Bank - Online 1.85
HSBC Premier 2.19
HSBC Special 2.25
Kainga Ora - First Home Buyer Special 2.25
China Construction Bank Special 2.65
TSB Special 3.29
SBS Bank Special 3.45
The Co-operative Bank - First Home Special 3.45
ICBC 3.49
Resimac 3.54
First Credit Union Special 3.59
Heartland Bank - Online 2.35
HSBC Premier 2.45
China Construction Bank Special 2.65
Resimac 3.89
TSB Special 3.94
SBS Bank Special 3.99
ICBC 4.05
First Credit Union Special 4.09
ASB Bank 4.15
AIA 4.15
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.35
China Construction Bank Special 2.99
HSBC Premier 3.19
Resimac 4.29
SBS Bank Special 4.69
TSB Special 4.70
Westpac Special 4.95
China Construction Bank 4.95
ICBC 4.95
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.99
BNZ - Classic 4.99
Kiwibank Special 5.15
ANZ Blueprint to Build 2.03
Heartland Bank - Online 2.25
ASB Back My Build 2.29
Resimac 3.39
Select Home Loans 4.09
Bluestone 4.09
Kiwibank 4.25
Kiwibank Special 4.25
Kiwibank - Offset 4.25
ICBC 4.25
China Construction Bank 4.49

More Stories

Auckland market turning for investors

Thursday, January 20th 2022

Auckland market turning for investors

Weaker prices for houses, particularly in Auckland, could mean the start of the long-anticipated downturn in the market.

Cracks appearing in housing market

Tuesday, January 18th 2022

Cracks appearing in housing market

A mortgage is not just getting more expensive as interest rates rise. A mortgage is now hard to get full stop, says Jarrod Kerr, Kiwibank chief economist.

Minister orders enquiry into CCCFA

Friday, January 14th 2022

Minister orders enquiry into CCCFA

Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs David Clark has acknowledged concerns with the CCCFA and ordered an enquiry.

CCCFA “not understood” by politicians

Monday, January 10th 2022

CCCFA “not understood” by politicians

The ACT Party believes the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act (CCCFA) was not properly understood when it went through parliament and is now asking for a review.