Static Auckland rents suggest underlying problem

Thursday 13 December 2018

Overcrowding could be the real reason that Auckland rents haven’t budged for months while Wellington rents have rocketed up to match those in the SuperCity.

By Miriam Bell

The median rent in the capital was up by 5.8% year-on-year to hit a record high of $550 per week in November, the latest Trade Me rental price data reveals.

In contrast, Auckland’s median weekly rent remained firm on $550, for the eighth month in a row, in November. While it was up by 3.8% on last year, it has flat-lined for much of this year.

That means Wellington rents now match Auckland’s for the first time ever.

Head of Trade Me Rentals Aaron Clancy says that looking ahead to the busy January and February period they think Wellington City could overtake Auckland City to become the most expensive place to rent. 

“Demand for rentals in the capital is showing no sign of slowing down, with 12 of the region’s rentals in the country’s 20 most popular rentals in November.”

The Wellington rental market is struggling to keep up with demand, he says.

“In November there were 4% fewer rentals in Wellington than the year prior. We’re also seeing sharp dips in Lower Hutt and Porirua which are down 14% and 30% respectively.”

But, given Auckland has a well-recorded housing supply shortage, the data does beg the question of why Auckland’s rents have not risen in the way Wellington’s have.

Clancy says that after solid rent increases throughout 2017, the heat has come off the Auckland rental market. He thinks rents are likely to start rising again in the New Year when many leases are up for renewal.

NZ Property Investors Federation executive officer Andrew King is not so sure. He says it may be that Auckland’s rents have reached a point where affordability issues are at play.

“My feeling is that growing numbers of people are moving in with each other, so that there will be more people in each house.

“If tenants are struggling to pay rents, overcrowding is an inevitable outcome. And that could be what is going on in Auckland.”

There has been a lot more building going on in Auckland which could be helping ease supply pressures a bit, he says.

“But I’m concerned we are going to run into further problems when new regulations increase the cost of providing rental properties and landlords either try to raise the rents or simply get out of the market.

“The result is likely to be an even greater shortage of rental properties and a further increase in overcrowding and homelessness.”

Meanwhile, the Trade Me data shows the national median weekly rent was unchanged for the fourth month in a row in November. It remains on $480 per week, which is a 4.3% increase on last year.

Clancy says that most regions saw a year-on-year increase in rents in November with strong double-digit growth in Gisborne, Otago, Southland and Hawke’s Bay.

Another rental market to watch is Otago’s. It is also struggling with a major shortage of rental stock and that’s keeping prices high.

Otago’s median weekly rent was up by 11.3% year-on-year to $418 in November, while the region’s city, Dunedin, saw its median weekly rent rise by 8.3% on last year to $390.

Clancy adds that the rental market will be one to watch in the coming months after the recent ban on letting fees for rental properties came in to force this week.

“It’s likely we will see this expense passed on through rent increases so tenants may need to dig deep into their pockets in the New Year.”

Read more:

Tight supply means rent rises 

Landlords to bear letting fee costs 

Comments from our readers

On 13 December 2018 at 11:52 am John Butt said:
This column is based on Trademe who do not see actual prices, they only have quoted prices, and they are not always the prices charged. MBIE publish actual prices based on bond data. Wellington is very short of private rental properties, while Auckland has plentiful supply, see my real comparison here - based on MBIE published data of actual rents.
On 14 December 2018 at 5:13 pm John Butt said:
Lets have another go on the accuracy of using trademe pricing data. MBIE released their new bonds data today in the form of their geometric mean rents by region, the most reliable rent prices there are. Auckland $526pw vs Wellington $440pw. There is no substitute for good stats, the asking price is not a good stat for anything. By all means Trademe have excellent details on the supply numbers, ie number of listings as per my charts, but the remaining data would be better ignored.

Sign In / Register to add your comment

Property News

Homesellers required to provide IRD number

Investors who flip properties are currently subject to the bright line test, but owner-occupiers are not. That is now set to change.

House Prices

Market rebound coming - Westpac

The cancellation of a capital gains tax combined with lower mortgage rates will be game changing for the housing market, believes Westpac’s chief economist.


Transforming commercial investment

Many investors are switching from residential to commercial property and now a new platform aims to makes access to the sector easier.


Investor lending weak in March

The latest Reserve Bank lending data reveals investors borrowed more than $1 billion in March, the highest figure since November, but a 10% fall on the same period last year.

Site by PHP Developer