KiwiSaver market share leader ANZ at bottom of performance table

The report ranks ANZ multi-sector funds’ performance last or second to last place in conservative, balanced and growth categories for both the December quarter as well as the 2024 year, although returns were all in positive territory. Over longer time periods, ANZ does perform better compared to peers in the moderate fund category, ranking middle of the pack for the 10-year period.

At the top performing end, Quay Street features in first and second across a range of time periods for conservative and balanced funds. Milford continues to deliver consistently high performance over the long term, although returns in the short to medium have suffered of late. Generate is ranked in the top five for a range of time periods and across different fund categories.

Of the default funds, BNZ, Booster, Superlife and Simplicity lead the table for the three-year time period, followed by Fisher Funds and Westpac.

The average diversified funds category returns for the quarter had a range of 1% for conservative to a strong 5% for aggressive growth assets, with Morningstar reporting annual returns followed a similar trend.

Growth in funds invested continues unabated

KiwiSaver assets grew to $121.9 billion in the December quarter, up close to $24 billion for the 2024 year. 

ANZ remains in the lead for market share with $22 billion under management, while ASB is in second position, with a market share of 15.0%. Fisher Funds, Westpac, then Milford make up the top five.

“The five largest KiwiSaver providers account for approximately 66% of assets in our database, or around $81 billion under management,” says the report.

“We estimate these five providers will deduct more than $650 million dollars in fees in 2025 from KiwiSaver members, at an average fee of around 0.80 of a cent per dollar invested.

“This mirrors the overall market fee levels in terms of average dollar invested.”

Murky economic waters

Taking a bird’s eye view of economic conditions, Morningstar describes the final quarter of 2024 as a mixed bag for the economy.

“While some indicators pointed towards a potential upswing, others suggested continued headwinds,” says the report.

“Globally, economic uncertainty persisted, with geopolitical tensions and varying growth trajectories across major economies.”