Opinion

[OPINION] When a Bill’s objective is vague, its provisions are rudderless

Parliament’s Environment Committee released its reports on the Natural and Built Environment (NBE) and Spatial Planning Bills last week.

Monday, July 03rd 2023

By Dr Bryce Wilkinson

The New Zealand Initiative

The committee’s Labour majority is recommending the modified Bills be enacted.

But the recommended NBE Bill looks as unworkable and misguided as its earlier version. It has 12 parts, 861 sections, and 15 Schedules.

The problems start with the NBE Bill’s purpose statement. It does not identify any problem in the community for which the bill is the remedy.

Its stated purpose, “to uphold te Oranga o te Taiao”, (the health and wellbeing of the environment) is unfathomable. We are not told who is not upholding it, why not, or why it matters.

The meanings it is given are as all-encompassing as motherhood and apple pie.

Who decides what is the “health of the environment”, meaning everything inside and outside our homes and all our relationships with each other? And how does it help to say its meanings include “the interconnectedness of all parts of the environment”?

The courts will likely spend a decade fathoming the unfathomable.

National, ACT and the Greens each have their own opposing minority recommendations.

In the words of ACT’s minority view: At the highest level, the bill’s purpose is to “to uphold te Oranga o te Taiao”.

“This is given a list of vague definitions with completely new terminology without any hierarchy. The bill throws in vague and puzzling concepts without any definition. How courts will interpret such confusing statements is unknown. This is a recipe for judicial mayhem.

“Judicial mayhem is not the rule of law.”

National promised to repeal the Bill, if elected.

Its forthright objections are summarised in this extract from its concluding comment: “The bills fail on almost every front. They are anti-democratic. They disregard fundamental property rights.

“They will lead to extensive, time-consuming and costly litigation. They will increase bureaucracy. They put at risk our climate goals. They will likely increase the costs, time, and uncertainty of resource consents. We cannot support these bills.”

Meanwhile, the Green Party objected that the bill is too supportive of the provision of infrastructure – roads, wind farms, housing – to adequately reduce “environmental harm”.

The RMA failed in good part because its prime objective -- “sustainable management” -- was not a solution to any identified problem.

Labour’s Bill has the same fundamental flaw, while likely throwing consenting into turmoil for years.

It should not pass.

Comments

No comments yet

Most Read

SBS FirstHome Combo 4.39
Unity First Home Buyer special 4.69
Co-operative Bank - First Home Special 4.89
TSB Special 4.99
ANZ Special 4.99
ASB Bank 4.99
Kiwibank Special 4.99
Westpac Special 4.99
AIA - Go Home Loans 4.99
ICBC 4.99
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.99
Nelson Building Society 4.97
Kainga Ora 4.99
ICBC 4.99
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.99
Wairarapa Building Society 4.99
Unity 4.99
TSB Special 4.99
ANZ Special 4.99
ASB Bank 4.99
Westpac Special 4.99
AIA - Go Home Loans 4.99
Westpac Special 5.39
ICBC 5.49
BNZ - Classic 5.59
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 5.69
ASB Bank 5.69
SBS Bank Special 5.69
AIA - Go Home Loans 5.69
BNZ - Std 5.79
Kainga Ora 5.79
TSB Special 5.89
Kiwibank Special 5.89
SBS FirstHome Combo 4.19
AIA - Back My Build 4.44
CFML 321 Loans 5.25
Co-operative Bank - Standard 6.20
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 6.20
Heartland Bank - Online 6.25
Kiwibank Special 6.50
Kiwibank - Offset 6.50
Kiwibank 6.50
Unity 6.64
TSB Special 6.64

More Stories

Four decades of 6-7% yearly house price growth ending

Friday, March 21st 2025

Four decades of 6-7% yearly house price growth ending

New Zealander’s reliance on property capital gains in the mid-single digits is at an end.

[TMM Podcast] Yelsa serves up “marine reserve” of property buyers

Friday, January 31st 2025

[TMM Podcast] Yelsa serves up “marine reserve” of property buyers

It’s been years in the making and former real estate agent Mike Harvey is now coming to market with his platform matching buyers and sellers, an offering he says will be a gamechanger for the industry.

Leaving last year's stumbling housing market behind

Friday, January 17th 2025

Leaving last year's stumbling housing market behind

As interest rates ease and job losses climb, New Zealand’s housing market faces a mixed year of modest growth, with conflicting forces shaping the outlook for homebuyers and investors.

Don’t bet on house prices rising faster than incomes

Wednesday, January 15th 2025

Don’t bet on house prices rising faster than incomes

Former Reserve Bank Governor and National Party leader Don Brash says there are grounds for believing that house prices may finally have ended the three-decade period when they rose significantly faster than incomes.