[OPINION] Property always goes up or does it?

This has always been true. Then, one day, it was not.

Tuesday, March 28th 2023

By Simon Angelo - Wealth Morning

In Auckland, home prices are down nearly 22%. More than in almost any other global city.

How did this happen? And what will happen next?

Let’s start from the beginning…

The typical mum and dad investor in New Zealand builds up some wealth, then buys a rental property or two. I’ve met many of them. They’re planning for their retirement. A good thing to do.

Today, the rental property sector is a bigger asset class by GDP than in other developed countries.

There have been years of overfishing in that small pool. It’s now rare to find a residential investment that delivers any decent actual net yield.

By actual net yield, I mean the return from rent after all the costs and time involved.

So, by definition, these investors depend on healthy capital gains. Which, to be fair, we have seen over the past decade.

Yet, there are no certainties when it comes to investing for the future. Only probabilities.

I see headwinds coming from two directions. With the probability of being financially hazardous.

1. High property prices (by measure of median-income) are still unsustainable

These prices depend on historically low interest rates for the most part. High rates of net migration. And restrictive building/zoning.

When interest rates rise rapidly — as we’ve seen following Covid’s monetary overshoot — the rug gets pulled from under home prices.

As we track toward variable mortgage rates of 10%, values could crumble further.

There is also the risk of economic shock or trauma. About 12.5% of the adult population already has debt in arrears. Debt they cannot afford.

Of course, when the cycle turns and interest rates start coming down, this could see values grow again.

Which puts us in the firing line of another, wider headwind risk…

2. Political pressure will keep coming for the ticking time bomb of unaffordable housing

The cost of housing has often ranked as the country’s biggest election issue.

There was pervasive anger when first-home buyers found themselves losing out at auctions to investors, only then to see the same home listed for an astronomical rent shortly after.

Labour’s first drastic solution was to deny investors the ability to deduct mortgage interest. Along with an extension to the Brightline ‘capital gains’ test.

National, not known for much drastic action, then teamed up with Labour to force medium-density standards across all the major cities.

Some very blunt legislation that does enable supply — but in the process threatens to kill off the Kiwi way of life with bunker blocks.

The ACT Party was the only party in parliament to oppose this, instead proposing other solutions to incentivise building, infrastructure, and drive supply.

Alongside National, it has also campaigned to restore interest deductibility for investors.

But this doesn’t yet resolve the political issue of many younger Kiwis still priced out of the housing market. People who feel a sense of hopelessness because they may never own a home in New Zealand.

We need to recognise housing as a necessity. As shelter. A vital — yet once built — unproductive asset class. We also need to see home ownership as an investment in society. A public good.

If one owner of that asset class — investors — can deduct mortgage interest, then all owners with a mortgage ought to be able to do so. (This was the case when I lived in Europe).

In many other jurisdictions, mortgage on interest for rental properties is treated differently:

  • in the UK, landlords cannot deduct mortgage interest but can receive a tax credit based on 20% of that interest bill;
  • in the US, all home owners may qualify for a mortgage tax deduction on up to $750,000 of borrowings. In fact, the Home Mortgage Interest Deduction (HMID) is one of America’s most cherished tax breaks — incentivising home ownership;
  • in Italy, a 19% tax deduction on mortgage interest is available to all home owners, subject to certain limits;
  • in Denmark, interest on mortgages is deductible for all home owners; and
  • in Switzerland, mortgages for home owners are fully tax deductible.

In New Zealand, the situation before was no tax incentive for home ownership. Only for landlords, who thus gained a competitive advantage.

In fact, the country had among the lowest tax support for owner occupiers in the OECD:

Tax deductions should be used to incentivise desirable activity. In particular, home ownership across society.

We have now moved the incentive dial toward building more housing. New build rentals can still deduct mortgage interest. This makes sense. Not the misaligned incentive for investment into existing and constrained housing stock.

Now, those with mortgaged rental properties will likely be up in arms at this point.

Yes, you’ve worked hard to provide warm and dry housing someone may rent. But, often, you are also renting out a home that could have been bought by an owner-occupier.

And, no, your rental property is unlikely to be a viable business. A study on the sector showed the average rental property returning around 0.3%. But this was before most moved off interest deductibility and rates were lower. Meaning, today, most are probably loss making. Any profits depend on speculative capital growth.

If you put many rental properties against listed businesses, they would be uninvestable by return on equity alone.

National and ACT were tracking to win this year’s election.

Yet if they fail to get the housing crisis under control, the stage is set for more drastic opposition from the other side.

Property in New Zealand doesn’t always go up. It’s not a one-way bet. But it is the Kiwi dream that every New Zealander can one day own their home.

Some say the New Zealand economy has been failing to deliver for too many people for too long.

Unaffordable housing, wages not keeping pace, unsustainable household debt, and surging division are all signs of that.


On Wednesday, March 29th 2023 4:09 pm Maxwell K said:

Simon, an excellent article and one I am in total agreeance with. In regards to residential investment properties,I really do question, given the rules and regulations around the responsibilities of being a landlord, why anyone would bother in the present economical times. If it wasn't for the capital gains made over the last decade benefit, I don't think many landlords would have made any money. I have for a long time now,thought for around the same money as you would pay foe a residential in the main centre's, a well selected industrial or small commercial investment property would have been a much better choice for many investors.

On Wednesday, March 29th 2023 4:36 am Peter Lewis said:

I could not disagree more strongly. Residential renting can be a viable business. It is for me, I make a reasonable six-figure income from my residential landlording, and I have friends who do the same. Every now and then academics and analysts carry out a study on the return from buying an average priced house and renting it out at an average rent level. They - quite correctly - then deduce that the return from doing this is so poor that those who invest in rental property must be doing it solely for the capital gain. This is then used to reinforce their argument that 'we need a CGT'. Where their study falls down is that successful property investors do not buy an average house and the rent it out for an average rent. They buy well, often buying where a property needs improvement or where alterations and renovations can increase rental income, or from a vendor who for their own reasons are desperate for a quick sale. Having bought that property and rectified whatever is wrong for it they then get a profitable return. Thats where the skill of being a successful investor lies, and not many people possess that skill. Despite what these studies portray, its not a matter of simply buying any property at any price, chucking a tenant into it, and standing back waiting for the gold bars to fall out of the sky. The deductibility of mortgage interest for rental property providers is not 'a tax loophole' - any business in NZ is entitled to deduct interest paid from their taxable income. Once more, we have a unique and special penalty applied to, and only applied to, residential landlords and no-one else. And do farmers, owners of public company shares, those who buy and sell businesses and those who resell commercial property pay a tax on their capital gains? Landlords deduct mortgage interest payments from their income because they pay tax on any profit made from rent they receive. If home-owners want fairness by having the same benefit, then to be fair they will have to pay tax on the currently tax-free accommodation they receive as the profit of owning that property.

SBS FirstHome Combo 6.14
Unity First Home Buyer special 6.55
Co-operative Bank - First Home Special 6.79
Heartland Bank - Online 6.89
Wairarapa Building Society 6.95
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 6.99
Kiwibank Special 6.99
Unity 6.99
TSB Special 6.99
ICBC 7.05
China Construction Bank 7.09
Unity First Home Buyer special 6.45
Heartland Bank - Online 6.55
SBS Bank Special 6.69
ICBC 6.69
TSB Special 6.75
Westpac Special 6.75
ASB Bank 6.75
AIA - Go Home Loans 6.75
China Construction Bank 6.75
Kiwibank Special 6.79
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 6.79
SBS Bank Special 6.19
ASB Bank 6.39
Westpac Special 6.39
ICBC 6.39
AIA - Go Home Loans 6.39
China Construction Bank 6.40
Kiwibank Special 6.55
BNZ - Classic 6.55
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 6.55
TSB Special 6.59
SBS Bank 6.79
SBS FirstHome Combo 6.19
AIA - Back My Build 6.19
ANZ Blueprint to Build 7.39
Credit Union Auckland 7.70
ICBC 7.85
Heartland Bank - Online 7.99
Pepper Money Essential 8.29
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 8.40
Co-operative Bank - Standard 8.40
First Credit Union Standard 8.50
Kiwibank 8.50

More Stories

Sticky market for investors – first home buyers in control

Wednesday, May 15th 2024

Sticky market for investors – first home buyers in control

Large numbers of property investors have not come back into the market despite  the reintroduction of 80% interest deductibility for landlords and the lowering in July of the Brightline test from 10 years to two years, QV says in its latest update.

Low house prices and deposits help first home buyers

Thursday, May 09th 2024

Low house prices and deposits help first home buyers

The increasing number of low deposit mortgages being lent to first home buyers has been borne out by the latest CoreLogic research.

Rate cuts needed to lift mood

Wednesday, April 17th 2024

Rate cuts needed to lift mood

The enthusiasm that followed the change in government, mainly from property investors, has waned as homeowners and buyers hang out for interest rate cuts, says Kiwibank.

Support for regulation

Monday, March 18th 2024

Support for regulation

REINZ has emphasised the need for property management regulation to Parliament’s Social Services and Community Committee.