Opinion

COMMENT: The good, the bad and the ugly

The Government's housing policy is full of good, bad and plain ugly. NZ Property Investor magazine publisher Philip Macalister explains.

Wednesday, March 24th 2021

The Government played its first-hand on how to win over the housing market. Will it work or not is the unanswered question, but politically this is an issue Labour has doubled down on and will not give up. There may be other hands to play.

The ugly

Removing deductibility of mortgage repayments is cynical and inequitable.

For a large group of investors this is likely to be at the margins. NZ Property Investor magazine’s annual survey of landlords shows investors are generally not highly geared.

For many the strategy is to pay down the mortgage and then live off the income generated from rents.

The ones who will be hit are the newer, more highly leveraged investors. I know of a 26-year-old who has three rentals and has done it to provide for his future. He is highly leveraged and the changes will make a significant impact, unless he can reduce his debt significantly in four years' time.

It is totally inequitable that the Government punishes people who are making efforts to generate their own income rather than live off state hand-outs.

Likewise other businesses can deduct interest payments, why not property investors? They are running legitimate businesses that supply accommodation to New Zealanders.

The good

Investing in infrastructure is long overdue. We are based in Rotorua and development of new sections is hindered by the council’s lack of investment in infrastructure. NZME reported on Ashworth Villas which has been unable to get across the line due to inadequate wastewater infrastructure.

In other areas of the city landowners want to subdivide but council can’t supply water and wastewater.

These stories are not isolated. They repeat themselves across the country.

The (not-so) bad

Increasing the bright-line test to 10 years. Most investors won’t care. As our surveys show most investors are long-term buy and hold.

The idea investors are all speculators is one of the biggest lies told by any government. It is factually untrue and insults hard-working Kiwis who want to look after themselves.

The bad

Tenants will suffer. Property investors don’t have too many levers to pull when more imposts are put on them. They either increase rents (just like transport companies do when fuel prices go up) or they sell up.

It’s hard to argue against the notion the market is out-of-control when it comes to house prices, but it’s also such a complex market that putting effective controls in place is nearly impossible.

Many people agree the answer is in the supply side.

The Government should consider a middle ground, put measures in place to cool things down until supply increases and then remove the measures.

Comments

On Saturday, April 24th 2021 4:02 am Steve Baron said:

Good commentary.

Heartland Bank - Online 1.85
HSBC Premier 2.19
Kainga Ora - First Home Buyer Special 2.25
HSBC Special 2.25
SBS Bank Special 2.55
China Construction Bank Special 2.65
Kainga Ora 2.88
ICBC 2.89
TSB Special 2.94
First Credit Union Special 2.95
Resimac 2.98
Heartland Bank - Online 2.35
HSBC Premier 2.45
China Construction Bank Special 2.65
Resimac 2.79
SBS Bank Special 2.95
Select Home Loans 2.99
Nelson Building Society 3.24
Kainga Ora 3.28
ICBC 3.29
TSB Special 3.40
First Credit Union Special 3.45
China Construction Bank Special 2.99
HSBC Premier 3.19
Select Home Loans 3.54
Resimac 3.54
TSB Special 3.94
SBS Bank Special 3.95
ICBC 4.09
Kainga Ora 4.22
Bluestone 4.29
SBS Bank 4.45
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.49
ANZ Blueprint to Build 1.68
ASB Back My Build 2.04
Heartland Bank - Online 2.25
Resimac 3.39
Select Home Loans 3.49
Bluestone 3.74
Kiwibank Special 3.75
Kiwibank 4.00
Kiwibank - Offset 4.00
ICBC 4.15
Kainga Ora 4.43

More Stories

House price growth on the downward slide

Thursday, October 28th 2021

House price growth on the downward slide

House price growth has dropped from a quarterly rate of 8.1% in April to 4.8% by September.

Tribunal: Anti-social behaviour – tenancy terminated

Monday, October 25th 2021

Tribunal: Anti-social behaviour – tenancy terminated

A tenant who cut the Sky cable, removed fuses from the fuse box and put them back incorrectly, and tagged items on the premises has had his periodic tenancy terminated.

Investor juggernaut slowly grinding down

Friday, October 22nd 2021

Investor juggernaut slowly grinding down

Property buying by mortgaged investors is back down to the levels just before the loan-to-value restrictions were lifted in the second quarter last year, which sparked investor demand back into life.

FOMO haunts property buyers

Wednesday, October 20th 2021

FOMO haunts property buyers

Fear of missing out (FOMO) is rising in the residential property market. Sally Lindsay reviews the figures from Tony Alexander and REINZ.