Property Management

What landlords can't ask tenants

Think you know what you can ask a prospective tenant? It might pay to check out the Privacy Commissioner’s new guidelines to see if what you are asking really is acceptable.

Wednesday, May 22nd 2019

Impending changes to tenancy law, along with the damage liability issues generated by the infamous Osaki decision, means that careful tenant selection is now of even greater importance for landlords.

However, exactly what information a landlord, or property manager, can ask for when selecting a tenant has often been mired in controversy.

Last August, it was revealed that some property managers were asking to see the bank statements of prospective tenants.

This prompted heated dialogue over exactly what information requests from landlords, when selecting a tenant, are reasonable and what requests could constitute an invasion of privacy.

Now the Office of the Privacy Commissioner (OPC) has released a new set of guidelines outlining what information should and should not be collected by landlords when selecting a tenant.

Privacy Commissioner John Edwards says that landlords are entitled to collect personal information where that is necessary for their lawful purpose of selecting a tenant.

“As a landlord, you want tenants who will care for your property and fulfil their obligations. The pre-tenancy stage is an opportunity to gather information that will help you make your decision.

“However, you need to balance this with the privacy of your prospective tenants. You may only collect information that’s necessary for you to decide whether they would be a suitable tenant.”

He says the guidelines are designed to help landlords make a reasonable decision about what personal information to collect from prospective tenants.

The guidelines group information requests into three categories - ‘always justified’, ‘sometimes justified’ and ‘almost never justified’.

According to this system, that means it is fine for a landlord to ask whether a prospective tenant has ever been evicted or for authorisation to perform a criminal check.

But it is very rarely okay for a landlord to ask about conflicts with previous neighbours and building managers or for credit card information or proof of insurance.

It is, however, sometimes justified for a landlord to ask for current income verification or for authorisation to collect a credit report.

Edwards says it may be lawful for landlords to collect information to assess whether a tenant can pay rent.

“But collecting their bank statements to determine their money management style may be unfair or unreasonably intrusive. Landlords should only collect the minimum amount of personal information necessary to make that decision.”

The guidelines might provide clarification but they also add a further level of complication into the search for good tenants.

That’s because while tenant selection has always been tough, the changing rental environment means landlords are now keen to access as much information from prospective tenants as possible.

Auckland Property Investors Association vice-president Peter Lewis says the reason for that is that the current Government is making it increasingly difficult to get rid of unsatisfactory tenants.

“This means landlords will naturally be a lot more cautious about who they select as a tenant in the first place. No-one with the slightest blemish on their record will, in time, have any chance of gaining a tenancy.”

*The Privacy Commissioner’s guidelines on the collection on personal information by landlords can be read here

Read more:

Proof rent can be paid crucial 



On Wednesday, May 22nd 2019 2:31 pm John Butt said:

Interesting, I notice they include emergency contact twice. We always ask for next of kin, I guess the two could be the same but not always I guess

On Thursday, May 23rd 2019 8:06 am Property Leader said:

I asked the Privacy commissioner how I could check if a tenancy applicant had multiple identities. It is of course quite normal and legitimate for people to have multiple names like relationship changes etc. I got two answers. One said they could not advise me how to do this and the other said if a person wants to rent a property, it is reasonable to expect that they prove who they say they are. From this I take it they might not know how to work out if someone had more than one name. Or else they are trying to entrap me. What do readers think?

On Thursday, May 23rd 2019 4:25 pm Sheryl Glasse said:

I always ask for photo id to prove who they are.

On Thursday, May 23rd 2019 4:26 pm Sheryl Glasse said:

They say you can't really ask for drivers licence details - you need to have it to do a credit check.

Heartland Bank - Online 1.85
ICBC 2.15
SBS Bank Special 2.19
HSBC Premier 2.19
HSBC Special 2.25
Kainga Ora - First Home Buyer Special 2.25
The Co-operative Bank - First Home Special 2.29
Kiwibank Special 2.49
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 2.49
ANZ Special 2.50
TSB Special 2.50
Heartland Bank - Online 2.35
ICBC 2.35
HSBC Premier 2.45
Kiwibank Special 2.49
SBS Bank Special 2.49
China Construction Bank Special 2.65
Resimac 2.79
TSB Special 2.89
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 2.89
Westpac Special 2.89
ANZ Special 2.90
China Construction Bank Special 2.99
HSBC Premier 3.19
ICBC 3.19
Kainga Ora 3.37
Bluestone 3.54
Select Home Loans 3.54
Resimac 3.54
SBS Bank Special 3.59
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 3.79
TSB Special 3.79
Westpac Special 3.79
ANZ Blueprint to Build 1.68
ASB Back My Build 1.79
Heartland Bank - Online 1.95
Resimac 3.39
Bluestone 3.49
Select Home Loans 3.49
ICBC 3.69
Kiwibank Special 3.75
Kiwibank 3.75
Kiwibank - Offset 3.75
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.40

More Stories

LVRs kicking in for Auckland house prices

Friday, July 16th 2021

LVRs kicking in for Auckland house prices

The loan-to-value (LVR) restrictions reintroduced by the Reserve Bank are having a far greater effect on Auckland house prices than anywhere else in New Zealand.

Dire shortage of properties for sale

Wednesday, July 14th 2021

Dire shortage of properties for sale

The total number of properties for sale across the country dropped by 33.3% last month. The second lowest level of inventory ever, REINZ data shows.

ASB hikes rates across the board

Wednesday, July 14th 2021

ASB hikes rates across the board

ASB has become the first major bank to hike interest rates across the board as New Zealand's economic outlook improves.

Investors urged to bolt in long-term rates

Tuesday, July 13th 2021

Investors urged to bolt in long-term rates

With high inflation just around the corner, ANZ Bank, the country’s biggest mortgage lender, says mortgaged property investors would be wise to fix at least some of their borrowings at longer-term rates.