Outrage over CGT recommendation

Thursday 21 February 2019

Introducing a capital gains tax on rental properties will have a detrimental effect on both the rental market and house prices in the long-term, property investors warn.

By Miriam Bell

The Tax Working Group’s recommendation that a capital gains tax should be introduced on a range of assets, including rental properties, has prompted outrage from many investors.

While the TWG believes that, on balance, a capital gains tax will lead to "some small upward pressure on rents and downward pressure on house prices”, investors have a different view.

NZ Property Investors Federation vice president Peter Lewis says a capital gains tax will not impact on the property market in the way that the TWG is expecting.

He says many investors will sell up their rental properties before the tax regime changes and this might lead to some short-term decrease in prices.

“But far more people live in rental properties than in owner-occupier properties so it won’t help with the shortage of rental accommodation and that will place upward pressure on rents.

“Alternatively, investors simply won’t sell their properties, particularly after a tax is introduced, so there will be less properties on the market which, ultimately, makes for higher house prices.”

Veteran property investor Olly Newland, who describes the recommendations as a “dog’s breakfast”, agrees.

He says a capital gains tax would have a detrimental effect on the rental market overall and it won’t make the housing market any more affordable.

“People will look for ways around the tax. So instead of investing in assets like rental property or shares, they will lock their money into family homes and lock in their capital gain that way.

“There are plenty of people who make good money by buying and then selling the family home. That will just increase.”

According to the TWG, the capital gains tax recommendation is driven out of concern about fairness in the tax system, but most investors take a different view.

Property commentator Ashley Church says the fact that the TWG has recommended a capital gains tax should be set at an individual’s marginal tax rate, which could be up to 33%, is very aggressive.

“It comes under the guise of being impartial and fair but that’s just not true: it actually slams the sectors of the electorate who are most unpopular with those who vote for this Government.”

He too says it will have a terrible effect on the rental market at a time when it is continuing to struggle with major supply shortages.

“I think it is scary stuff and is out of touch with how the economy and productivity works. It is not going to invest people to invest in businesses. It is likely to do the opposite of that.”

For prominent Auckland investor David Whitburn, the recommendation is far more extreme than he would have expected and reeks of the politics of envy.

He doesn’t believe the general public will support a capital gains tax that is as broad as proposed and points to recent polls showing a large majority of people, including Labour voters, as opposed to one.

“I think they have misread the electorate if they think it will fly. People might have warmed to it if was solely targeting property investors but it’s not. It will apply to assets like the family bach and farms too.

“So it will elicit an emotional response, as well as attacking the aspirational nature of Kiwis and their dreams for the future and plans for retirement.”

Whitburn adds that if the Government is serious about weeding out property speculators, but rewarding good long-term landlords, it could simply extend the bright line tax to 10 years.

All of those interviewed thought that introducing a capital gains tax was likely to be electoral suicide for the Coalition Government.

Most also questioned whether the recommendation would even be adopted by the Government, given NZ First’s long-stated opposition to the idea of a capital gains tax.

But Church says the idea of a capital gains tax must have been canvassed in the Coalition agreement talks so the odds are NZ First will agree to some form of one.

He thinks the TWG’s recommendations are likely to be a more extreme version of what the Government eventually goes with.

Read more:

Capital gains tax on the cards 

War over capital gains tax begins 

CGT would be repealed under National 

It’s a capital gains waiting game 

Comments from our readers

On 22 February 2019 at 11:41 am Nozzle said:
Rental properties are purchased with income already taxed. Now they want to tax the gain funded by tax-paid income. Unbelievable!
On 22 February 2019 at 5:23 pm Alan W said:
So the TWG, in its 'wisdom' has apparently made no allowance for things such as inflation and the increasing value of a house as a result of extending it. So if a person has vacant land and builds on it, they pay CGT on the cost of the new build as well as the inflation on the land? You have got to be joking!!

Sign In / Register to add your comment

House Prices

Pushing up the national average price

The main centres used to drive New Zealand’s market but it was strong provincial markets that contributed to the national average asking price’s rise in July.


Join the office space revolution

Flexible working spaces are more than just a fleeting trend and the launch of a new co-working serviced office franchise programme will open up the market to investors.


OCR cut could prompt housing market upturn

The Reserve Bank’s decision to slash the Official Cash Rate (OCR) by 0.5% to a historic low of 1.0% has shocked the financial community, but what could it mean for the housing market?

Site by PHP Developer