COMMENT: Ring-fencing rules could mean 116,000 less rentals

Ring-fencing of rental losses on rental properties could end up resulting in 116,000 fewer rentals, Stop the War on Tenancies spokesman Mike Butler cautions.

Tuesday, February 12th 2019

In response to an Official Information Act request, I received confirmation from Inland Revenue last week that 116,000 rental property owners declared a loss on earnings in the 2016/17 tax year.

Inland Revenue also said that the average loss declared by each owner was $7138, and that includes both individual and non-individual (trusts, partnerships and companies) taxpayers.

Owners who run a rental property at a loss do so to claim the losses against tax paid on their day job to get a refund.

Yet advice to the Government about the impact of loss ring-fencing has proceeded without anyone knowing how many private rental property owners are negatively geared.

A figure of 40% was given in that advice without stating the total number of private rental property owners.

In fact, the 116,000 number now received from Inland Revenue is much higher than I expected and it means that we could be looking at up to 116,000 fewer rental properties on the market.

That’s because once a rental property owner has to top-up his or her rental with $138 every week from their day job and with a greatly reduced chance of ever getting it back, it won’t be long before that owner decides to sell.

Early last year Inland Revenue and MBIE advised the Government that ring-fencing losses would result in the sale of an unknown number of properties to owner occupiers, reducing availability of rentals and increasing rents by around 10%.

MBIE thought the housing shortage would increase by 16,600 over the two years from 2018, when taking into account the building of 6,000 KiwiBuild homes over that period.

Those briefing papers were produced under the expectation that KiwiBuild would deliver 6,000 dwellings in two years.

But just three weeks ago, Housing and Urban Development Minister Phil Twyford said he could not guarantee that the Government will meet its target of having 1,000 KiwiBuild houses built by July.

That means the 6,000-extra-dwelling figure is now off the table.

If every negatively-geared owner then sold to an owner-occupier, and if each owner then sold one property, the shortfall would be more like 116,000 properties, not 16,600.

The looming new rules relating to the ring-fencing of rental losses mean it’s decision time for negatively-geared owners.

But it is also decision time for the Government as it may unwittingly create a further massive shortfall of rental properties by not listening to advice.

Submissions on the bill relating to the ring-fencing of rental losses close on February 28. Those with something to say on the topic can make a submission here.

Mike Butler is a Hastings-based owner and manager of rental properties. He is also the founder of Stop the War on Tenancies.

Read more:

Ring-fencing Bill hits Parliament

Tax policy could heighten rental crisis


On Tuesday, February 12th 2019 1:18 pm BArt said:

Hmmm... We sold our rental for other reasons (future maintenance req.).Anyway, I digress.... If housing stock of rental quality is being sold, and it is then sold to an owner/occupier (else it would be rented again), then the negative consequence you state is rents increasing by 10%. Do you mean because of supply and demand? Also where will the xtra renters come from to create the "massive" shortfall. Didn't a number of those renters just become owner/occupiers? Unless the property sold is being rented out again! See? Sorry devils advocate here :-)

On Thursday, February 14th 2019 11:45 am Mstenbo said:

I agree with previous comment. This article makes some bizarre assumptions. If 116,000 properties are dumped on the market at short notice the price will plummet and one of 2 things will happen. Either landlords will withdraw them from the market because they can't afford to sell in the new market or tenants will buy the houses because they will be able to afford it. Landlords are earning plenty. They might be declaring a loss of $138 per week but with average capital increases of $1000 per week TAX FREE they don't really have much to complain about. Property investment is grossly under-taxed in NZ and allowing negative gearing is just a further tax avoidance bonus for landlords. Bear in mind that I say all this as a self-managing residential property investor for over 15 years who has benefited well from negative gearing as well as a lack of capital gains tax. There is no war on tenancies, there is a war on inequality.

Heartland Bank - Online 1.99
Kainga Ora - First Home Buyer Special 2.25
HSBC Premier 2.25
ICBC 2.45
Westpac Special 2.49
SBS Bank Special 2.49
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 2.49
BNZ - Classic 2.49
ASB Bank 2.49
ANZ Special 2.49
TSB Special 2.49
HSBC Premier 2.35
Heartland Bank - Online 2.35
ICBC 2.45
TSB Special 2.49
ASB Bank 2.59
SBS Bank Special 2.65
Kiwibank Special 2.65
China Construction Bank Special 2.65
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 2.69
AIA 2.69
Westpac Special 2.69
HSBC Premier 2.89
SBS Bank Special 2.99
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 2.99
AIA 2.99
Westpac Special 2.99
BNZ - Classic 2.99
ICBC 2.99
ASB Bank 2.99
China Construction Bank Special 2.99
Kiwibank Special 3.19
TSB Special 3.19
Heartland Bank - Online 2.50
Resimac 3.39
Kiwibank - Offset 3.40
Kiwibank 3.40
Kiwibank Special 3.40
Bluestone 3.49
ICBC 3.69
Heartland 3.95
The Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.40
The Co-operative Bank - Standard 4.40
Kainga Ora 4.43

More Stories

Just 14 days until new healthy homes standards kick in

Tuesday, November 17th 2020

Just 14 days until new healthy homes standards kick in

It is just two weeks now until healthy homes standards compliance statement need to be included in new or renewed tenancy agreements.

Reserve Bank looks to bring back lending restrictions

Wednesday, November 11th 2020

Reserve Bank looks to bring back lending restrictions

The Reserve Bank plans to reintroduce loan to value ratio restrictions on mortgage borrowers from March next year following a surge in the housing market.

Tribunal divvies up blame in maintenance ruling

Friday, November 06th 2020

Tribunal divvies up blame in maintenance ruling

New Zealand’s aging housing stock and tradition of informal landlord-tenant relationships have the potential for complex disputes where fault lies with both parties – as illustrated by a recent Tenancy Tribunal ruling.

COMMENT: The importance of correct structuring

Thursday, November 05th 2020

COMMENT: The importance of correct structuring

Structuring the ownership of a property portfolio is rarely the first – or even the second - thought for new investors. But it should be, argues property accountant Anthony Appleton-Tattersall*.