NZ market out of step with Australia’s slump
Thursday 31 January 2019
New Zealand’s housing market might be cooling but it’s in sync with global trends – unlike the Australian market’s dramatic decline, according to a major bank.
By Miriam Bell
Warnings that Auckland’s market could follow the downward plunge of Sydney and Melbourne’s markets continue, but ANZ chief economist Sharon Zollner says that the extent of the Lucky Country’s decline is unusual.
In ANZ’s latest Property Focus, the bank’s economists compare recent developments in the housing markets of Australia, the US, the UK and Canada.
Zollner says they found that global house markets – and prices - are looking synchronised in the current downswing.
“Each market is experiencing its own idiosyncrasies with little sign so far that contagion is an issue. Outside of Australia there is so far no sign of anything unusual about the slowdowns.”
However, the behaviour of certain Australian markets has generated a lot of attention because they are particularly dramatic.
This week CoreLogic downgraded their outlook for Australia’s housing market. It is now predicting values in Sydney and Melbourne will fall 18% to 20% from peak to trough.
Most Australian property markets analysts expect the decline to continue although predictions on how much vary.
AMP forecasts a 25% drop in Sydney and Melbourne and Credit Suisse picks a 25% price fall for Sydney, but National Australia Bank expects prices to drop 15% in Sydney and ¬Melbourne.
Zollner says their data shows Australia’s housing market weakness is widespread, but most severe in Sydney, Melbourne and Perth, where prices are lower than they were a year ago.
“Forward indicators for the Australian housing market such as the auction clearance rate suggest that weakness is likely to continue.
“ANZ expects peak-to-trough house price falls of 15-20% in Sydney and Melbourne, with prices to continue falling throughout 2019.”
Of the housing markets ANZ looks at in its comparison, Australia’s is the most correlated with New Zealand’s, with Sydney and Auckland house prices often moving together.
But Zollner says correlation is not causation and the correlation reflects that drivers of the two markets – like interest rates, foreign investor demand and broader economic cycles – have tended to move together.
“At the moment, the primary driver of the housing market weakness in Sydney and Melbourne is sharply reduced availability of mortgage credit, partly related to the Royal Banking Commission, and emerging oversupply in the apartment market.
“Neither of those two things are a feature of the Auckland or the broader New Zealand housing markets. “
Going forward, most commentators expect the New Zealand market, and particularly Auckland’s market, to continue slowing but they don’t anticipate price falls similar to that being seen in Australia.
CoreLogic head of research Nick Goodall says their expectation is that the 2019 property market will see much of the same as 2018.
“Risks do remain, but we have a solid footing. We anticipate that property sales volumes in 2019 will be similar to 2018 with average values probably rising by around that 3% figure again.”
However, while values nationwide are generally rising, they do remain sluggish in Auckland and Christchurch, he says.
Comments from our readers
No comments yet
Sign In / Register to add your comment
It’s been a spectacular run for the market but this property cycle has done its dash and recent positive developments aren’t likely to cause a major upturn, one top economist says.
Technology and changes to the way people work are set to transform the commercial property sector and investors need to be attuned to these developments.
The latest Reserve Bank lending data reveals investors borrowed more than $1 billion in March, the highest figure since November, but a 10% fall on the same period last year.