Property

CGT by stealth

A five year bright line test for residential property sales is now a reality but critics say it’s a capital gains tax by stealth.

Wednesday, March 28th 2018

Tax legislation extending the current bright line test from two years to five has now passed its third reading in Parliament and is expected to be in force by the end of the month.

The extension means that profits from residential properties which are bought and sold within five years will, generally, be taxable.

However, the existing exemptions - which include the sale of an owner-occupier’s main home, inherited property, or the transfer of property in a relationship settlement – will remain.

Revenue Minister Stuart Nash says the change will help dampen property speculation and make homes more affordable.

“This proposal will ensure that residential property speculators pay income tax on their gains and makes property speculation less attractive.

“We need investment which grows the economy and creates jobs, not the sort of investment which distorts the residential housing market. This measure will bring fairness back into the tax system.”

The legislation, which was fast-tracked through Parliament and passed by 63 votes to 57, was opposed by National and Act.

It was the previous National-led government that first introduced the bright line test but the party’s finance spokesperson, Amy Adams, says the extension is a duplicitous way of introducing a capital gains tax.

In her view, a two year period rather than a five year one is a better way to catch speculators because many people who are not speculators will buy and sell property in the course of the longer period.

ACT leader David Seymour also says the extension of the bright line test means that New Zealand now has a capital gains test in all but name.

“The five year bright-line test means that many New Zealanders will find themselves paying tax when they sell a home.”

However, Seymour put the blame for this at the feet of the National Party, saying a two-year bright line test should never have been introduced.

“There is no evidence that a capital gains tax charged over any length of time will reduce house prices as claimed.

“Some of the worst housing affordability in the world is in Sydney, Vancouver, London and Los Angeles, all cities with capital gains taxes.”

Many investors believe the extension of the bright line test is another factor that will make investing in property more difficult and could contribute to a dramatic increase in rents.

But Auckland Property Investors Association president Andrew Bruce has previously said the majority of investors are in it for longer than five years.

For that reason, he thinks many investors are unlikely to feel massive levels of pain due to the extension of the bright line test.

Read more:

Bright line test extension fast tracked 

Shock awaits for tax avoiders 

Comments

No comments yet

Most Read

Unity First Home Buyer special 3.99
ICBC 4.25
SBS FirstHome Combo 4.29
Co-operative Bank - First Home Special 4.35
TSB Special 4.39
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.45
ANZ Special 4.49
ASB Bank 4.49
SBS Bank Special 4.49
Unity Special 4.49
Westpac Special 4.49
ASB Bank 4.49
TSB Special 4.49
AIA - Go Home Loans 4.49
SBS Bank Special 4.49
Kainga Ora 4.49
BNZ - Std 4.49
Kiwibank Special 4.49
Wairarapa Building Society 4.59
Nelson Building Society 4.59
ICBC 4.59
Unity Special 4.65
ICBC 4.99
BNZ - Std 4.99
SBS Bank Special 4.99
Kainga Ora 5.15
ASB Bank 5.15
AIA - Go Home Loans 5.15
Westpac Special 5.29
TSB Special 5.39
Kiwibank Special 5.39
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 5.49
BNZ - Classic 5.59
SBS FirstHome Combo 3.29
AIA - Back My Build 3.34
SBS Construction lending for FHB 3.74
CFML 321 Loans 3.95
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.99
Co-operative Bank - Standard 4.99
Heartland Bank - Online 5.30
ICBC 5.39
Kiwibank - Offset 5.65
Kiwibank 5.65
ANZ 5.69

More Stories

Buyers sitting on the sidelines in best time to buy in a decade

Thursday, December 04th 2025

Buyers sitting on the sidelines in best time to buy in a decade

Stable house prices, low interest rates and plenty of houses to choose from are still not enticing buyers.

Differing views on 50-year mortgage

Tuesday, December 02nd 2025

Differing views on 50-year mortgage

US president Donald Trump recently raised the idea of 50 year mortgages; but New Zealand advisers say such long loans won’t take off in New Zealand.

Houses selling at a loss hit a 12 year high

Wednesday, November 26th 2025

Houses selling at a loss hit a 12 year high

About one in five Auckland residential properties (19.3%) sold for less than their original purchase price in the third quarter, up from up from 15.9% in the second quarter.

OCR Preview: How far is far enough for the RBNZ?

Friday, November 21st 2025

OCR Preview: How far is far enough for the RBNZ?

Economists expect the OCR to drop another 0.25% to 2.25% next week, with a 50/50 chance of another cut in February.