Land tax not the way to go

Tuesday 26 April 2016

Stamp duty or a new build restriction would be more effective than introducing a land tax for non-resident buyers, property experts say.

By Miriam Bell

Over the weekend, Prime Minister John Key raised the possibility that a land tax for non-resident property buyers could be introduced – if evidence shows they are pushing up house prices.

Such a land tax could also impact on non-resident New Zealand citizens with property in New Zealand, although Key told media they would have to have been non-resident for some time.

Suggestion of such a land tax has been greeted with dismay by many in the property sector.

Positive Real Estate director Campbell Venning warned that introduction of a land tax could foreshadow the introduction of a capital gains tax.

“I can see where the government might be coming from politically, with such a land tax. But it is opening up the Pandora’s Box to a capital gains tax, and I don’t think anyone in property wants that.”

Venning said he was all for foreign capital coming into New Zealand, but did think that – as with foreign investment in shares and business – it should be taxed.

It was a double-edged sword though because doing so would put greater focus on money-generating property.

“There would be real time visibility on the sector and the government might decide to make it more black and white and simply say ‘if you are making money on property you should be taxed on it’.”

But he added that the world is moving towards a more international tax system and New Zealand is starting to play catch-up.

Other alternatives – such as reinstituting a stamp duty or restricting foreign buyers to the purchase of new builds – would be more effective, according to commentators.

Veteran property investor Olly Newland said a land tax wouldn’t work because overseas buyers will keep buying as it is still worthwhile for them.

“Imposing stamp duty on local sales for everyone, with the exception of first home buyers, would be a much better solution.”

He said a stamp duty would mean that much bigger cash lump sums were required for deposits which would slow down many buyers.

“The government needs to do something to curb the market without collapsing it and stamp duty would do that without affecting prices to much.”

In his view, the necessary legislation for stamp duty would be far easier to introduce than that required for a non-resident land tax.

Property Institute chief executive Ashley Church said taxing foreign investors might make a few people feel better, but it would do little to slow down house price inflation in the Auckland market.

He is a long-time advocate of the approach adopted by Australia whereby non-resident property buyers are restricted to only buying or building, new houses.

If these rules are breached, non-resident buyers are liable for large fines.

Church said the government should adopt such a policy for New Zealand.

“It would be a much more effective way of slowing down house price increases in the medium term because it would address the shortage of supply rather than trying to artificially dampen demand.

“Rather than penalising those who want to invest in our real estate market, we should be channelling that investment into getting more homes built, more quickly.”

NZ Initiative research fellow Jason Krupp said the introduction of a land tax was a simple, knee jerk reaction to a complex problem.

But the current housing crisis is the manifestation of multiple problems and the government should be addressing the various issues creating the problem.

“Supply is key. The government should be addressing regulatory factors – like the long term funding of infrastructure, incentives for councils, and the lingering impact of the leaky home crisis on consent processes – in order to boost supply.”

Comments from our readers

No comments yet

Sign In / Register to add your comment

House Prices

Regions lead the price growth pack

Provincial markets stole the asking price spotlight from the main centres in January, according to the latest Trade Me Property Price Index.


Headwinds for the commercial market

Tightening credit conditions could impact on New Zealand’s booming commercial property market, according to the Property Council’s chief executive.


Heartland launches reverse mortgages for investors

Heartland has expanded its reverse mortgage business and will now lend against investment properties and second homes, as the product becomes more popular in New Zealand.

Site by PHP Developer