Opinion

How much is your house worth?

If you asked me to put a value on the house I live in, I’d probably find it pretty difficult.

Tuesday, February 19th 2013

There’s the CV, of course. Then there’s what a similar house has sold for just  the corner. Then there’s what I’d like to think it’s worth, and then again there’s how much it might cost to build if all I had was the section.

But under changes to insurance policies set to happen this year, I’ll have to put a figure on it – and I’ll have to make sure I get it right. Otherwise, I could be left seriously out of pocket if disaster strikes.

IAG has confirmed that it will switch its policies from full replacement cover to agreed value some time this year. So if an earthquake hits and wipes out my house, I’ll only get paid out the amount we’ve agreed on – not whatever it takes to build a new house.

This raises some questions. What happens if we agree on a figure now, and then there’s a major disaster that puts pressure on the construction industry, forcing up prices? Will I have to build a smaller house because the $500,000 (or whatever figure we agreed on) now doesn’t cut it when construction firms are having to compete for labour or materials?

Most houses cost more to build than the sell for second-hand at the moment.  If the insurance value is tied to the CV, as has been suggested, how well does a property’s CV cater for the cost of a new build?

I can understand the insurance companies’ point of view – reinsurers want to know exactly what they might have to stump up for in the event of a large-scale disaster – but getting the dollar figures right will be crucial, especially for property investors.

Comments

On Tuesday, February 19th 2013 3:33 pm Andy said:

Conversely, with bulk discounts and other ways in which insurance companies manage to worm out of paying up, what happens if we over-insure? Do we get a refund, or the balance paid out in the form of reduced or waived excess? A prudent investor or property owner would add an extra $50k to the value, just to protect themselves from the reported inflationary factors and production stresses already mentioned. But this could easily result in a 25-30% premium increase for the insurance companies with no actual increase in risk. An alternative may be where consumers can purchase an indemnity type insurance that could cover any loss due to under insurance on the day. The insurance companies knew what they were in for - that is the job of the bean counters. If they paid more attention to the risks that they already knew of (liquefaction, fault lines, ground structure, marshlands and other risk factor research etc) instead of trying to increase premium income, they would not be in this situation. Much of the information that has been made public was already public 30 years ago, and some as early as 1900 (liquefaction in Kaiapoi and the recommendation that building not be continued in that area, as an example). Sour Grapes - HELL YES! I have been waiting over 2 years to have my house fixed, yet if I had missed ONE premium, the insurance company would have been on my tail like a greyhound on a hare! It is about time the insurance companies stood up and accepted the risk, the same way they happily accepted our premiums without due diligence! Or am I totally wrong?

On Tuesday, February 19th 2013 3:53 pm Natalie said:

From what I hear, if your house burns down, it is relacement. Best probably to have a house in Chch as we had our big one!

On Wednesday, February 20th 2013 10:14 am Paul said:

Dont forget to add in demolition costs as well. This comes out of the agreed value.

Most Read

Unity First Home Buyer special 3.99
SBS FirstHome Combo 3.99
TSB Special 4.39
Co-operative Bank - First Home Special 4.39
ICBC 4.39
SBS Bank Special 4.49
Unity Special 4.49
ANZ Special 4.49
Westpac Special 4.49
Kiwibank Special 4.49
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.49
ICBC 4.59
ANZ Special 4.69
TSB Special 4.69
BNZ - Std 4.69
Wairarapa Building Society 4.79
Nelson Building Society 4.87
Westpac Special 4.89
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.89
Kiwibank Special 4.89
SBS Bank Special 4.89
Unity Special 4.89
ICBC 5.19
Westpac Special 5.29
TSB Special 5.29
BNZ - Std 5.29
SBS Bank Special 5.69
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 5.69
Kainga Ora 5.69
ASB Bank 5.69
AIA - Go Home Loans 5.69
Kiwibank Special 5.79
Westpac 5.89
SBS FirstHome Combo 3.29
AIA - Back My Build 3.34
SBS Construction lending for FHB 3.74
CFML 321 Loans 3.95
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 4.99
Co-operative Bank - Standard 4.99
Heartland Bank - Online 5.30
ICBC 5.39
Kiwibank - Offset 5.65
Kiwibank 5.75
Unity Standard 5.79

More Stories

Thursday, February 19th 2026

RBNZ expects slower house price growth in the current recovery

The Reserve Bank thinks house prices will rise at a much slower pace during the current recovery than they have in past cycles.

Wednesday, January 07th 2026

Queenstown not off the radar for first home buyers

First home buyers are not being deterred by Queenstown’s soaring house prices.

Record levels of first home buyers taking out low deposit loans

Tuesday, December 23rd 2025

Record levels of first home buyers taking out low deposit loans

About half of all first home buyer lending has been done at a less than 20% deposit in recent months.

Buyers sitting on the sidelines in best time to buy in a decade

Thursday, December 04th 2025

Buyers sitting on the sidelines in best time to buy in a decade

Stable house prices, low interest rates and plenty of houses to choose from are still not enticing buyers.