Opinion

Not as much tax in residential property as TWG says

Friday, March 19th 2010

I wasn’t expecting an Auckland University think tank on retirement income was the sort of crowd who would drop a bombshell on the Tax Working Group, but that’s exactly what they did yesterday.

The Retirement Policy and Research Centre, headed by well-known superannuation commentator Michael Littlewood released a paper which questioned the accuracy of one of the TWG’s numbers on the property market. By questioning the group’s predictions on the size of the residential investment market it also casts significant doubt over the assumptions made about how much revenue the government can raise by putting new taxes on property investors.

To his credit Finance Minister Bill English was quick to comment on the research and even acknowledged it may mean changes to their thinking.

He says Treasury analysis was showing that changes to property tax would make a smaller contribution to government tax revenue than what was estimated by the TWG.

Pity his side kick Peter Dunne on the revenue side hasn’t listened. He made a speech today with the same old line that changes to the tax treatment of property were likely, to make the rules fairer and more equitable for all taxpayers.

Some of the questions one has to ask is what other fundamental errors did the TWG make? Also one wonders whether they were in fact just a ginger group set up to stir up a debate and prepare Kiwis for radical – and unpopular changes – as opposed to an objective working group.

I know last week’s Blog, where we talked about some numbers produced by the NZ Property Investors Federation. It calculated that if the government goes ahead with changes to depreciation rules for residential property investment then rents are likely to rise. Landlords, it estimates, would lose on average $1750 a year if they lost the tax deduction and this amounted to $34 a week, which would be passed on to tenants.

These calculations provoked a response that that this numbers from the federation where use political statements lacking analysis.

Judging by what we have seen from the Retirement Policy and Research Centre there are questions that need to be asked about the TWG and its plans.

The good news out of this is that maybe there is hope that the government will not be as harsh on the residential property sector as first indicated. We will know on May 20 – Budget Day.
Heartland Bank - Online 6.69
SBS FirstHome Combo 6.74
Wairarapa Building Society 6.95
Unity 6.99
Co-operative Bank - First Home Special 7.04
ICBC 7.05
China Construction Bank 7.09
BNZ - Classic 7.24
ASB Bank 7.24
ANZ Special 7.24
TSB Special 7.24
Unity First Home Buyer special 6.45
Heartland Bank - Online 6.45
China Construction Bank 6.75
TSB Special 6.75
ICBC 6.75
ANZ Special 6.79
ASB Bank 6.79
AIA - Go Home Loans 6.79
Kiwibank Special 6.79
BNZ - Classic 6.79
Unity 6.79
Westpac Special 6.39
China Construction Bank 6.40
ICBC 6.49
SBS Bank Special 6.55
Kiwibank Special 6.55
BNZ - Classic 6.55
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 6.55
ASB Bank 6.55
AIA - Go Home Loans 6.55
TSB Special 6.59
Kainga Ora 6.99
SBS FirstHome Combo 6.19
AIA - Back My Build 6.19
ANZ Blueprint to Build 7.39
Credit Union Auckland 7.70
ICBC 7.85
Heartland Bank - Online 7.99
Pepper Money Essential 8.29
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 8.40
Co-operative Bank - Standard 8.40
First Credit Union Standard 8.50
Kiwibank 8.50

More Stories

Support for regulation

Monday, March 18th 2024

Support for regulation

REINZ has emphasised the need for property management regulation to Parliament’s Social Services and Community Committee.

A better investment market

Thursday, March 14th 2024

A better investment market

“Reinstatement of interest deductibility starting from the new tax year on 1 April brings property investors back in line with every other business in the country, where interest costs are a legitimate deductible expense," Tim Horsbrugh, New Zealand Property Investors Federation (NZPIF) executive committee member says.

[OPINION] Recessionary times

Thursday, March 14th 2024

[OPINION] Recessionary times

It is not the best out there for many businesses and property sector people. Sales are down across the board, our clients’ confidence is falling, and there is a lot of uncertainty.

Interest rate expectations: It’s not over yet

Thursday, March 07th 2024

Interest rate expectations: It’s not over yet

Most Kiwis think interest rate increases have peaked.