Schemes benefit a lucky few
Tuesday 29 January 2013
Something that both the Green and Labour housing affordability policies have in common is that they are great for those in a position to buy houses through them. They are less good for everyone else.
The Greens believe they can sell Government-owned homes worth $300,000 without the buyers having any need for a mortgage.
Each week tenants would pay $200 to meet Crown costs, $100 towards their share of the home and $50 for any extra costs - that's $350 dollars a week to own a home outright in 25 years.
For the tenants who will be getting a brand-new home for less than what a lot of people are paying in rent, it’s a great deal.
But the numbers don’t stack up: It’ll be other taxpayers who finance these low-income families into their homes.
That’s been proved by Labour’s recent backtracking.
The party seems to have come to the realisation that its KiwiBuild numbers don’t make sense. Leader David Shearer had been talking about building 100,000 new homes to be sold for $300,000 each.
So convinced was he about the affordability of the scheme, he said money left over from the sale of each swathe of homes would be reinvested in construction of the next year’s new housing.
Now he says it’s not possible to build a standalone house for that price in Auckland and that $300,000 is the national average. In Auckland, standalone houses will still cost about $550,000.
These policies aren’t sustainable or fair.
No one disagrees that more families owning their own homes is something to aspire to.
But why do we feel compelled to give these families brand-new homes, supported financially by every other New Zealander?
And are we expecting that those families helped into extremely cheap homes would then be altruistic enough to sell them on at less than market price in future? Or might they - quite reasonably - eventually sell their houses for exactly the sort of unaffordable price the politicians are trying to combat?
We need a sustainable solution that makes housing development cheaper for everyone. Not just lovely new houses for a select few.
Comments from our readers
Sign In / Register to add your comment
Impending doom might seem to be on the cards following China’s share market meltdown, but economists believe that, at this stage, prospects are not as dire as media coverage suggests.
More evidence of the “Auckland effect” comes in the latest Real Estate Institute of NZ data which shows that, in July, Auckland’s median price fell by 2.6%, while the national median price rose by 3.3%.
New, more targeted regulations for earthquake-prone buildings are a win for commercial property owners and businesses.
The Reserve Bank has cut the OCR to 3.25% today. Here is what the governor Graeme Wheeler said.