Mistaken rent refund

Andy asks:
(updated on Friday, March 23rd 2012)

A rental agency paid money back to a tenant that was moving out as they believed it was overpaid rent. Letters were sent to confirm this. Two months later it was discovered that the rental agency got it wrong. Can the rental agency claim the money back?

Our Experts Answer:

The answer to this question depends very much on the particular facts of your case but on the surface the answer is yes. If a person receives money paid in mistaken belief that it is theirs then the misunderstanding does not make that person entitled to it. A misunderstanding about the facts does not change the facts. However, there are several things to consider. How much money are we talking about? Is it worth the time and effort pursuing the money? What sort of assurance did the confirmation letters give when the agency returned the “overpaid” money to the tenant? I suggest that the agency contact the former tenant and explain the error and try to negotiate the return of the refund. Failing an agreement, the Tenancy Tribunal process is available. Although (from a practical point of view) the agency had better have a very convincing story to persuade the Tribunal that it deserves a refund from the former tenant, after previously asserting that the tenant had overpaid the rent.

Select Home Loans 4.29
TSB Special 4.34
ICBC 4.39
HSBC Premier 4.39
Heartland Bank - Online 4.40
China Construction Bank Special 4.45
SBS Bank Special 4.55
Kainga Ora 4.57
Co-operative Bank - First Home Special 4.75
Kiwibank Special 4.85
AIA 4.85
Select Home Loans 4.86
Heartland Bank - Online 4.90
TSB Special 4.99
ICBC 5.09
HSBC Premier 5.15
SBS Bank Special 5.19
China Construction Bank Special 5.19
Kiwibank Special 5.19
AIA 5.35
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 5.35
First Credit Union Special 5.45
Select Home Loans 5.20
TSB Special 5.75
Kiwibank Special 5.79
HSBC Premier 5.89
ICBC 5.89
SBS Bank Special 5.95
BNZ - Classic 6.19
Resimac 6.33
China Construction Bank Special 6.35
Westpac Special 6.39
Kainga Ora 6.43
Select Home Loans 4.09
Heartland Bank - Online 4.10
Pepper Money 4.49
TSB Special 4.79
Liberty 4.84
Kiwibank Special 5.00
ICBC 5.25
Kainga Ora 5.43
China Construction Bank 5.50
Kiwibank 5.50
Kiwibank - Offset 5.50