SearchFight damage liability
Carrie asks:
(updated on Thursday, February 07th 2019)
My tenant states that an unknown neighbour came into her garage and a boyfriend followed her into the garage and that the two were fighting and caused damage to the garage door. My tenant claims she called the police and stayed inside while the couple was in the garage. There is damage to the garage door that the tenant wants me to pay for. Who is responsible for this damage, me or the tenant?
Our Experts Answer:
You haven’t said whose boyfriend was fighting. Was he the unwanted neighbour’s or the tenant’s? If either person in the garage was a permitted visitor, then the tenant is liable for permitted visitors and any damage that they cause.
I will assume for the purposes of this question that neither person fighting in the garage was invited nor permitted onto the property. In that case the tenant is not responsible for the damage these intruders caused. If the police were called, there will be a Police Incident Number tracking that call. I suggest you contact your insurance company and make a claim, quoting the Police Incident Number if required by your insurer.
Most Read
| Unity First Home Buyer special | 4.09 |
| SBS FirstHome Combo | 4.19 |
| ICBC | 4.49 |
| Kainga Ora | 4.59 |
| Co-operative Bank - First Home Special | 4.59 |
| AIA - Go Home Loans | 4.65 |
| ANZ Special | 4.65 |
| ASB Bank | 4.65 |
| SBS Bank Special | 4.69 |
| TSB Special | 4.69 |
| Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ | 4.69 |
| China Construction Bank | 4.95 |
| Kainga Ora | 4.95 |
| ICBC | 4.99 |
| Nelson Building Society | 5.09 |
| SBS Bank Special | 5.19 |
| ASB Bank | 5.25 |
| TSB Special | 5.25 |
| AIA - Go Home Loans | 5.25 |
| Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ | 5.29 |
| ANZ Special | 5.29 |
| Kiwibank Special | 5.29 |
| BNZ - Std | 5.49 |
| ICBC | 5.65 |
| Kainga Ora | 5.69 |
| Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ | 5.79 |
| SBS Bank Special | 5.79 |
| AIA - Go Home Loans | 5.89 |
| ASB Bank | 5.89 |
| TSB Special | 5.99 |
| Westpac Special | 5.99 |
| Kiwibank Special | 5.99 |
| China Construction Bank | 5.99 |
| SBS FirstHome Combo | 3.29 |
| AIA - Back My Build | 3.34 |
| SBS Construction lending for FHB | 3.74 |
| CFML 321 Loans | 3.95 |
| Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ | 4.99 |
| Co-operative Bank - Standard | 4.99 |
| ICBC | 5.39 |
| Kiwibank - Offset | 5.75 |
| Kiwibank Special | 5.75 |
| Kiwibank | 5.75 |
| Unity Standard | 5.79 |
