Dunedin experiencing growth
Monday 3 April 2017
The affordable investment market in Dunedin is in a growth phase, writes Jenny Keown.
After suffering an economic decline over the last decade, Dunedin is clawing its way out of the doldrums with a buoyant property market, building boom and workforce expansion.
In July last year, investors from Auckland and Central Otago turned their eyes to Dunedin when the 40% loan-to-value restrictions were introduced.
Harcourts Dunedin manager Richard Stringer says Otago stands out as it is such an affordable base, and there is real growth in Dunedin.
These thoughts are echoed by QV national spokesperson Andrea Rush who says the latest QV house price index shows value growth in Auckland, Hamilton and Christchurch continue to ease, while values are rising in Tauranga, Wellington and Dunedin.
Dunedin’s median price rose to $325,000 in January this year, up 8% from the same time last year, according to the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand. In Otago, the number of days to sell improved by four days from January 2016.
Where to buy
Dunedin doesn’t have any clearly defined residential investment areas says Stringer. Every area has its pros and cons, for example South Dunedin provides an affordable entry into the market, but isn’t such a desirable place to live, says Stringer.
Dunedin’s highest capital gains continue to be strongest in the student enclave of North Dunedin (4.4%) and Roslyn for apartments and flats (4.1%). Glenleith has the highest gross yield for housing at 8.4% with Dunedin central topping gross yield for apartments and flats at 7.5%, according to the Westpac Property Investor Report 2016.
Stringer says empty-nesters and families are relocating from Auckland to live in Dunedin as central Otago appeals for its affordable lifestyle, and good schooling.
Mana Property Management director Kyle Elmer says tenants tend to be a mix of young professionals, who are often graduates of the University of Otago, families and some students (although they don’t make up a large part of his tenancy portfolio).
Most tenancy agreements tend to be one-year fixed terms, and the young professionals will often renew after one year. On the question of whether the transience of the rental market is a challenge for investors, Elmer doesn’t think so, as long as investors get their numbers right.
“Investors get caught up thinking they can rent higher than what the market is paying,” he says.
He’s found government rental statistics aren’t often accurate and a number of key rental suburbs don’t seem to be included.
Overall, he says the market is much more buoyant in property sales and rents.
Dunedin-based property investor Kathryn Seque won the New Zealand Property Investor Federation’s Landlord of the Year in 2016. She and her father restore old houses into more appealing, warmer and drier homes for tenants.
She manages her father’s large portfolio of 45 student flats and owns four houses that she rents to young families.
Recently she bought a run-down house for $150,000 in Cranley Street, with an unusable kitchen, and mould-covered bathroom with no floor coverings. She spent $30,000 on renovating the place over six months which involved getting everything replaced, ripping out old scrim and fully insulating it. The house is now valued at between $285,000 and $300,000.
Another local investor, Mike Harbott, owns seven large student flats in North Dunedin.
He bought his eight-bedroom house on Duke Street for $230,000, invested $150,000 in to renovations and it is now currently valued at $650,000. Rents are $120 a room per week, and he gets a yield of 8%.
The yields on his other properties vary and the further the properties are away from campus the lower the yield, he says.
The lifeblood of Dunedin
The students who attend the University of Otago are still very much the life of the city, accounting for just over 20% of the population at the 2006 Census.
Elmer thinks the students occupy about half of the rental stock in Dunedin.
The perception of Dunedin as the place where students (affectionately known as ‘scarfies’) live in damp, dark and squalid places is changing though.
Seque says many students want and can afford better quality houses, particularly visiting students from Europe and Asia.
While she says the old, cold and damp houses still exist – landlords are wising up to the change in demand.
Every year, Seque pulls down at least one old ‘dunger’ and replaces it with a fully insulated, double-glazed flat, usually let to international students.
Their rents range from $115 per week for a room in their older flats to up to $180 p/w for their fully-furnished, brand new houses.
“Often you might find five students who will live in a three-bedroom flat to bring the rent down, and a lot of rents are subsidised by parents,” she says.
At the end of semester one, there is the first rush of students looking for flats. Often houses can be rented six months in advance of students’ return to university. There is another rush for properties between May and July, she says.
“If you don’t have anything rented by mid-November then you’re stuffed,” she says.
Advertising for students has become more competitive. “All we used to do was advertise on the Otago University website, but now you’ve got to use social media and if you don’t start advertising by June, you will have missed a lot of the market,” she says.
She’s had a pretty good run with the student tenants and she works hard to establish a good relationship with them from the outset.
“I have about two disputes a year, and I can generally predict which flat is going to be a problem. This year it is a flat of boys and I’ve been to see them five times in three weeks for not paying rent, partying and flat disputes,” she says.
One risk to be aware is Dunedin’s propensity for floods, particularly low-lying South Dunedin which used to be a marshland.
On February 13 this year, a short but intense burst of rain and hail caused flooding in parts of the city and the Dunedin City Council responded to 14 houses.
“In some houses in South Dunedin, you can feel like you are in a wave, the foundations are so out of whack,” says Seque.
Seque cautions investors to look before they buy, and make sure they know how to deal with flooding – employing a local property manager is a good idea, she says.
Where to from here?
Enterprise Dunedin director John Christie says the city experienced a decline over the last decade with the closures of significant companies, but Dunedin is a resilient community.
“Things are good for us now,” he says. Of course, the city wants growth, but not growth that puts pressure on the lifestyle enjoyed by Dunedin’s residents.
“We top a number of quality of life measures and people here are very conscious about all this,” he says. “You know, you wouldn’t want to go from a seven minute commute to a 10 minute commute,” he jokes.
Enterprise Dunedin, which is the economic development arm of the Dunedin City Council recognises that the city faces the risk of losing business and people to other cities. It is focused on developing the skills, incomes and job opportunities for its residents, according to its Economic Development Strategy 2013-2023.
Overall, Dunedin’s economic performance has improved over the past 10 years, but is not improving at a fast enough rate to better the national average in the foreseeable future, says the strategy.
Turning this around will require growth in population and labour utilisation, as well as productivity improvements across the city’s economy
The strategy aims to create 10,000 jobs over ten years and an average of $10,000 extra income for each person.
“As long as we grow availability of jobs, people will want to live here, and we are already seeing this with people shifting from Auckland,” he says.
There is a building boom in the construction sector and tradies are in hot demand, he says.
In 2016, the council processed 2717 building consents – the highest number in the past six years.
Building applications include some high profile developments such as the University of Otago Dental School redevelopment, restoration work on the Dunedin Courthouse and Otago Polytechnic student accommodation.
When it comes to the housing market, Stringer thinks there will be continued pressure for the next six to seven months, a slow-down during the election and then a return in confidence.
Harbott believes there is scope for Dunedin to continue to grow for another 12 months, given properties have an entry price of $200,000 and yields are strong.
Comments from our readers
No comments yet
Sign In / Register to add your comment
New Zealand may now have a government but uncertainty over what that might mean for the housing market is set to linger for some time.
Housing affordability in regions around New Zealand may have improved over the last quarter, but price to wage ratios are still sky high.
Commercial property syndicates give investors options and risks they might not otherwise have access to – but they do come with risks.
New Zealand’s lower economic growth was acknowledged by the Reserve Bank in its OCR statement today – which means there's a chance their next call could be more doveish.